The PFM Muscle AI Can’t Build
Automation can improve your finances without making you better at managing them.
I have a theory, and it goes like this:
The most interesting use case of AI in personal financial management may be giving thousands of creators the ability to turn their own 5% differentiator into software. Because 95% of personal finance advice is the same. The final 5% is what makes people actually follow it.
Here's what I mean.
There's been a lot of chatter about how AI has the capacity to "fix" personal financial management (including but not limited to the way OpenAI has explicitly positioned ChatGPT as a PFM tool, with more than 200 million users/month already asking it finance questions). The general idea is that people don't budget because they don't want to look at charts and graphs, so if only consumers could talk to something about their money instead, and let it take actions on their behalf.
That idea may be right. AI can help with the heavy lifting, but personal finance may be one of those spaces where the tool can't do the hardest part for you.
Ozempic is a great analogy for those looking to lose weight. It's a useful, almost AI-like shortcut, especially for anyone competing against Big Food (whose products are scientifically designed to be addictive, but I digress). Ozempic is a tool as opposed to the whole solution. If you take it without a serious weight training regimen and/or you lose too much muscle mass, you could end up physically frail rather than healthy. In other words, it controls cravings but it doesn't build the muscle. That part's still on you.
It's the same case with money. AI can sweep your paycheck, chase a better rate, and execute the trade. But it can't build your habits for you.
Religion offers another interesting analogy here. Strip back any major religion and roughly 95% is identical: belief in a higher power, the value of good works, the importance of community. Jewish people think their faith is nothing like Hinduism; Christians think theirs is distinct from both. But it's that distinctive 5% inherent to each religion that makes each faith distinct from the, say, foundational 95% that all faiths share.
Personal finance works the same way. Any course, guru, or system gives roughly the same advice: spend less than you make, save for long-term goals, let compounding work its magic. That's the 95%.
Dave Ramsey's 5% is the conviction to avoid all debt. Most financial experts wouldn't tell everyone to avoid debut, but Ramsey does, and it draws in people who've been burned by debt before. Once they're in, it's the 95% that improves their finances.
YNAB is a cult in the same way (and one Kiah belongs to). Four straightforward rules (with teeth), a book backing them up, and a community built around them. Once you're inside, you may find YNAB uses the same math as any other budgeting system. The difference is that found Jesse Mecham built the software to go with it, something most creators who know finance and content but not engineering, could never do alone.
You used to need a syndicated newspaper column or a daytime TV slot to build an audience, and you needed to be a programmer to build the product. YouTube and TikTok solved the first problem. AI can solve the second, letting any creator with a distinct 5% offering build the bespoke tool to match it, the way Jesse did with YNAB twenty years ago.
That could mean a thousand different PFM systems, each serving 10,000 people who already think the way that creator does. None of them need to be venture backed (which is good, because VCs hate personal finance anyway).
This leads me to the test you should hold up for any AI finance tool:
- What's the universal 95% that AI is making easier?
- What's the specific 5% that makes this particular group of people believe in it and stick around?
AI can automate the reps. The 5% is what gets someone to keep showing up long enough to build the muscle.
Related ResourcesCopy anchor linkCopied
- Here I Go Again - deep dive essay
- PFM 3.0 - deep dive essay
- Under the Hood - Highlights from the Fintech Takes Podcast
- The Primary Banking Agent - article in collaboration with Chime

